So I Read “Remain” and Now I Trust No One (Except Nicholas Sparks)

Book review: Remain by Nicholas Spark with M. Night Shyamalan

Genre: General Fiction, Paranormal, Romance, Mystery, Thriller

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I don’t even know how to begin talking about Remain without sounding absolutely unhinged. Truly. This book had me spiraling—and not in the typical Nicholas Sparks, cry-until-you’re-numb sort of way (though yes, you will need tissues). This one goes way deeper. More emotional, more intense, and way more supernatural than I ever expected.

Yes, you read that right. Supernatural. Because guess who teamed up with Nicholas Sparks for this absolute fever dream of a novel? M. Night Shyamalan. And once you know that, everything makes so much sense. The emotions hit as hard as ever (classic Sparks), but the atmosphere, the psychological twists, the slow unraveling of reality? Pure Shyamalan magic.

​I started Remain not knowing I would spend the next few days thinking about it constantly. I dragged myself through work like a zombie, counting the hours until I could get back to reading. Every spare second—coffee breaks, lunch, the awkward five minutes before a meeting—I was deep in my thoughts about this book. It got under my skin.

And here’s the thing: I went in expecting what we all expect from Sparks—beautiful people falling in love while life slowly tears them apart. But this? This was something else entirely. The romance is still there and still hits in that devastating, longing way Sparks is known for, but Remain adds an eerie, reality-bending layer that left me genuinely unsettled—in the best way.

I don’t want to give anything away, but let’s just say: this book messes with your head. You're cruising along, totally immersed in the emotional arcs and heartbreak and healing, and then—bam—you start second-guessing everything. What’s real? What’s imagined? What does it mean to truly stay connected to someone after they’re gone?

The story plays with time and space in a way that made me physically tense. I had chills. I actually woke up in the middle of the night spooked after reading. More than once, I had to take a breather to blink back into reality. It’s gripping. Atmospheric. And it hits this perfect balance of romantic and terrifying. There were moments I was swooning, and then suddenly I’d feel a creeping dread… followed by total emotional devastation.

It’s wild how well these two authors’ styles mesh. Sparks brings the soul; Shyamalan brings the shadow. Together, they create something hauntingly beautiful. I only hope the movie they’re supposedly creating—set to release a year after the book’s release, in October 2025, and starring Jake Gyllenhaal—lives up to this story. It’s the kind of book that makes you feel like something is standing just behind you while you read—and also that you’d risk it all for love, no matter what plane of existence it’s on.

The setting itself is more vague and fluid than in most Sparks books—not the familiar Carolina beach town, but something quieter, dreamier, and more surreal. It works so well. The story doesn’t anchor itself to a specific place—it exists in memory, in grief, in that liminal space between love and loss.

And can we talk about the twist?

Because… WHAT. I felt like I had the wind knocked out of me. That moment—if you know, you know—made me sit up and go back three pages to make sure I’d read it right. Then I immediately wanted to reread everything I’d already devoured, just to catch all the signs I missed. It was that good. Not gimmicky. Not over-the-top. Just quietly, powerfully mind-blowing.

This isn’t a book you finish and forget. It’s a book you carry with you. A book that whispers to you at red lights and grocery stores. A book that makes you wonder about your own memories, your own relationships—the things we hold onto, and the things that never really leave us.

Five stars. Easily. Not just because it’s beautifully written (it is), and not just because it made me sob (it did), but because it made me feel something new. It stretched what I thought a Nicholas Sparks story could be, and I loved that.

And honestly? I cannot wait to see what Sparks and Shyamalan do next. If this is the start of a new collaborative era, I am all the way in.

So if you want a love story that will break your heart and then blow your mind, Remain is for you. It’s romantic, it’s unnerving, and it’s one of the most compelling books I’ve read in a long time. 
​ 
Were you as wrecked by the twist as I was? Did you see it coming? And would you read more books like this from Sparks—ones that dip into the surreal and supernatural—or should he stick to emotional beach romances? Drop your thoughts in the comments. Let’s talk!

*I was given an advance copy of this book by the publisher/author in exchange for an honest review. This post reflects my personal impressions and was not influenced in any way. Please note that quotes or details may differ from the final, published version.